2027-2028 Theme: Trust and Credibility

Over the past two decades, financial crises, political polarisation, disputes over expertise, and the circulation of unreliable information have raised urgent questions about whom we trust and what makes language and institutions credible. The advent of powerful AI models has sharpened these concerns by inviting reliance on systems whose operations are partially or completely opaque. Such problems are far from being uniquely modern. Across history, while trust has enabled political and spiritual authority, economic exchange, and social cooperation, its contestation and collapse has exposed the vulnerability of apparently stable arrangements.

The Koch History Centre fellowship theme for 2027–2028 invites historians not only to investigate how trust and credibility have been established, contested and lost in different periods and regions, but also to consider how they shaped historical possibilities. How did societies create confidence in people, texts, objects, and institutions, who and what was deemed credible, who and what was excluded, and on what grounds? What role did documents, instruments, and technologies play in making truth-claims believable? Why did particular trust relations and forms arise when they did? Which arrangements endured, which failed, and what alternatives remained available?

Trust and credibility are closely related. Trust involves reliance on language, people, material structures, or institutions under conditions of uncertainty; credibility concerns the grounds on which individuals, texts, claims, and authorities are deemed worthy of belief. Distrust and the loss of credibility have significant histories, arising from deception, forgery, espionage, unequal power, failed promises, or contested authority, it has generated safeguards such as audits, guarantees, independent witnesses, and checks on power. How do social, linguistic, textual and institutional mechanisms create and maintain confidence in their operations and ‘credentials’, and how do they restore it when it is eroded or lost?

In the ancient world, trust was understood to be central to the operation of language and the relationship between rhetoric and dialectic. It lay at the heart of historiography as a self-reflexive discipline, operating across the boundary of recording what actually occurred and narrating what might plausibly have happened. It has also been central to the institutional analysis of ancient economies; for example, the understanding of credit and credit instruments has been transformed in recent years, but their broader social and economic consequences remain little understood. 

In medieval societies, trust was bound up with truth-claims about God, nature and human association. It could be cultivated through kinship, oaths, allegiance and religious affiliation, but also through narratives, documents, seals, witnesses and institutions that could confer credibility beyond autopsy and personal acquaintance. Such mechanisms sustained linguistic legitimacy, political authority, commercial exchange and religious communities. How did disputes over language, evidence, authenticity and obligation challenge established relationships of trust, and when did their breakdown create opportunities for institutional change or alternative forms of social, philosophical and literary authority?

Modernity is often told as the story of trust made impersonal. In that story, confidence passed from persons to procedures, from patrons to bureaucracies, from reputations to credit ratings, and from witnesses to scientific method. Yet modern religious authority, mercantile networks, imperial governance, scientific testimony, and financial institutions have continued to rest on personal ties and acts of faith, and their crises have repeatedly exposed that dependence - a fact that shows that effectively functioning trust relations often leave little documentary trace. Did modern institutions reduce the need for trust, or relocate it where it was harder to see and to contest? And where trust was absent, did empires, states, and markets rely on coercion to do without it?

We encourage applications from scholars working on any period or region who are seeking to offer novel accounts of the key roles that aspects of trust and credibility have played throughout history. Such proposals could, for example, address the causes of sudden, catastrophic collapses of trust and credibility, as in so-called Black Swan events. We particularly welcome applications that reflect on the extent to which such events are shaped or determined by long-term processes or by individual decisions: how can historians explain events without erasing the roles of contingency or chance?

Gillray, "Midas, transmuting all, into paper" (1797), Wikimedia Commons

Apply now